TrulyCar docs

Recalls & Safety · NHTSA & EPA data

2009 Toyota Highlander Recalls, Safety Rating & Owner Complaints

This sheet pulls NHTSA's public safety data for the 2009 Toyota Highlander together: recalls, star ratings and owner complaints. Use it to ask the seller better questions.

NHTSA rating

No overall score
rollover 4

Federal recalls

10

Owner complaints

174

EPA MPG combined

19–26

Factory Specs & MPG for this Highlander →

Federal safety recalls

10 10 recall campaigns on record

10 federal recalls is a lot, even for a popular SUV. For the 2009 Toyota Highlander, assume nothing about repair status: request the dealer's campaign-closure printout for the exact VIN, and walk away if the seller cannot produce it or the VIN shows open campaigns at nhtsa.gov.

Note that the recall list touches the air bags. Safety-critical campaigns like these are exactly what an unrepaired used car quietly carries forward to its next owner.

CampaignComponentReported
14V743000Seats: Front Assembly: Seat Heater/CoolerNov 2014
15V689000Visibility: Power Window Devices And ControlsOct 2015
14V168000Air Bags: Frontal: Driver Side: Inflator ModuleApr 2014
16V396000Seats: Front Assembly: Seat Heater/CoolerJun 2016
13V014000Air Bags: Frontal: Sensor/Control Module-InactiveJan 2013
10V035000Equipment: Other: LabelsFeb 2010
10V036000Equipment: Other: LabelsFeb 2010
09V223000Equipment: Other: LabelsJun 2009
10V023000Vehicle Speed Control: Accelerator PedalJan 2010
13V396000Hybrid Propulsion System: InverterSep 2013

NHTSA crash-test rating

— Not rated rollover 4

There is no overall NHTSA score for the 2009 Toyota Highlander, but the agency did rate parts of it: rollover 4 stars. The overall 5-Star score was introduced for 2011 models, so earlier years never carry one.

Owner complaints filed with NHTSA

The 2009 Toyota Highlander has attracted 174 owner complaints at NHTSA against a median of 49 for 2009 SUVs, well above what comparable vehicles draw. Read the pattern before you buy. The most common subject is the service brakes (55 reports). 5 of those reports describe a fire.

  • Service Brakes 55
  • Engine 27
  • Electrical System 23

What to check on a 2009 Highlander

At 17 years old, a 2009 Toyota Highlander is well past the point where model-year data predicts much. The individual car's history is everything: expect multiple owners, and treat any gap in the title chain as a question to answer before you pay.

This sheet covers one of 20 model years of the Toyota Highlander on record here (2005–2024); the 2009 is an early year in that run, and recall and complaint counts can differ sharply from one year to the next.

For an SUV, look for curb damage on the lower body and wheels, and confirm the all-wheel-drive system engages: a warning light that was cleared before the showing will come back.

Buying this 2009 Toyota Highlander from a private seller or dealership?

10 recalls on this 2009 Toyota Highlander. Do not guess which were fixed: check the exact VIN's open campaigns, title status and history on TrulyCar.com.

Check Full History & Salvage Photos on TrulyCar.com →

NMVTIS title check · accident records · auction photo archive · from $16.99

Other Toyota Highlander model years